19 members of the
Senate Judiciary unanimously voted to move forward with the Combating
Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act (COICA) this week, despite a
letter sent to them by a large number of law professors explaining the
unconstitutionality of COICA, and earlier protests by 96 Internet
engineers, and Tim Berners-Lee, the father of the Web.
However t doesn't appear it will pass through the full
Senate, at least for now.
COICA targets piracy, but it is very broad in its
definition of what that means. Copyright infringement could include not
just hosting torrents, downloads or streams of copyrighted materials,
but also providing a link or aggregated links to other sites or
Internet resources for obtaining access to such copies.
In other words, as defined, it could be interpreted
that a news site that linked to The Pirate Bay or other BitTorrent site
would be in violation. COICA would empower the attorney general to be
able to get court orders to blacklist sites out of the DNS (Domain Name
Service) system, meaning you wouldn't be able to type in their name and
reach them, on the Web. Naturally, organizations such as the MPAA and
RIAA love the idea.
Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) has announced that he was
going to take the necessary steps to stop [COICA] from passing the
United States Senate. He added: It seems to me that online
copyright infringement is a legitimate problem, but it seems to me that
COICA as written is the wrong medicine. Deploying this statute to
combat online copyright infringement seems almost like using a
bunker-busting cluster bomb when what you really need is a
precision-guided missile. The collateral damage of this statute could
be American innovation, American jobs, and a secure Internet.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) said: Blacklisting
entire
sites out of the domain name system is a reckless scheme that
will undermine global Internet infrastructure and censor legitimate
online speech.
As noted, the bill passed out of the committee
unanamously, which translates to having full bipartisan support. That's
pretty unusual in these contentious political times, and points to the
support of major industry organizations such as the previously
mentioned RIAA and MPAA. While probably dead for this session due to
Ron Wyden's opposition, it might show up again in the next.