Two
TV ads for the video game Condemned 2 have been censured by the
ASA
a. The first ad, which was cleared by Clearcast with a post-9 pm
restriction, showed scenes of violence including a man punching another
on the floor and blood splattering on the screen as a man was beaten
with a club. The ad ended with a close-up of an eye, surrounded by
blood, looking through a spy hole. On-screen text stated: CONDEMNED 2
Out Now ...
b. The second ad, which was cleared by Clearcast with a post-11 pm
restriction, was longer in duration. It included the same violent scenes
and on-screen text but also included further scenes and a voice-over
that stated Where is former agent Thomas? He must be warned, he must
know that it's not over. This time, as the characters fought, noises
could be heard which seemed to express pain and the force of their
exertions.
The ASA received nine complaints:
1. Most of the complainants thought ad (a) condoned violence and was
offensive and distressing. One complainant said the ad was inappropriate
for broadcast at any time.
2. Some of the complainants thought ad (b) condoned violence and was
offensive and distressing. Two complainants said the ad was
inappropriate for broadcast at any time.
ASA Assessment: 1. & 2. Upheld
We considered, however, that both the post-9 pm and post-11 pm versions
showed the same violent images of blood, beating with clubs and punching
and that, with the exception of duration, the differences between the
two ads were not significant.
We noted the ads were intended to demonstrate the likely experience of a
consumer playing the game. We considered, however, that the ads
contained scenes of graphic and brutal violence which, although
computer-generated, were realistic in appearance. We noted in particular
that both ads showed a man punching another on the floor and blood
splattering on the screen as a man was beaten with a club and considered
viewers were likely to find those scenes offensive and distressing and
to see them as condoning real violence and cruelty.
We considered that, with particular reference to the scenes described
above, they were likely to offend or distress some viewers whatever time
they were shown and both ads should be withdrawn from transmission
completely.
The ads breached CAP (Broadcast) TV Advertising Standards Code rules 6.1
(Offence), 6.2 (Violence and cruelty) and 6.4 (Personal distress).
|